Preseason Review
Here's a brief recap of all 4 fake Eagles games:
Bears
This was an awfully played game and even worse to watch. The things I took from the game was if you want to slow down and disrupt the Eagles offense have the refs call a penalty every other play on either team - it doesn't really matter who, and the defense is still at its weakest when the opposition has 3rd and long. What morons got from the game - Foles is a fraud because he threw 2 picks.
Patriots
Another terrible game to watch. The Patriots offense went up and down the field on the Eagles defense with ease as they continued to give up every 3rd and long they had either through a bad play or a penalty. The Eagles offense improved, but wasn't totally clicking like last year. The player of note was Jordan Matthews having a pretty good second half along with Mark Sanchize.
Steelers
As an Eagles fan this was a good game to watch. If you were a Steelers fan it was awful. The first and second team offenses drove with relative ease on the once vaunted first team Steelers defense. The Eagles defense had surprisingly good pressure and played much better overall though Roethlisberger and the Steelers looked terrible.
Jets
Despite few to no starters playing, this game was fairly watchable. The Eagles backups executed well, flags were at a relative minimum, and there were several standout plays. It helped that the Jets suck. The big story of the game was a kicker not named Henery made 2 field goals from beyond 50 so the Eagles are a lock to win the Super Bowl now.
Various evaluations from the fake games:
Foles - not as sharp as he was last year on touch passes, but he is throwing with more authority and velocity.
Sanchez - greatest backup in NFL history.
Barkley - if he didn't throw a ton of interceptions he could be a good backup someday.
McCoy - looks ready for a 5,000 yard season. Also appears he still gets easily winded despite claiming he's in the greatest shape ever.
Sprouls - looked decent. I guess he's under wraps until the games are real.
Polk - MIA
Maclin - caught almost everything thrown his way and when he didn't, his throw the flag gesture was so good you wouldn't even know he missed an entire season.
Cooper - in his one preseason appearance made 1 great catch but dropped 3 catchable ones.
Celek - will be a vegetable at 50.
Ertz - every beatwriter's favorite for a "break out year."
Casey - looked solid.
Allen Barbre - not good enough in pass protection. Will become a whipping boy as Lance Johnson serves his suspension.
Herremans - Solid as usual. Had good blocks downfield on some plays.
Mathis - had bad penalties in early games, solid now I guess.
Kelce - pretty damn good.
Peters - did the usual steamrolling guys.
As for the defense, all the starting secondary was getting burned or called for penalties. They will have to adjust or hope the NFL retreats on their renewed enforcing one of the most unfair, arbitrary, and frustrating penalties in the game. It no doubt will become a ploy of the receivers to run into a defensive back and fall down to draw an illegal contact call. I liked what I saw from free agent signing, Malcolm Jenkins. He played well and appeared to be a leader on the field and off. Others that played well included inside linebackers, Kendricks and Ryans. Vinny Curry stood out at times with good pass rushing as did Brandon Graham.
Rookie evaluations from the fake games:
Michael Smith II - mostly underwhelming so far, but you can see some of the touted athleticism and versatility. Sadly for a first rounder you're not supposed to be a project. Smith needs to learn how to play and figure out what he's doing to be effective in the NFL, and unfortunately for the team this will take time.
Jordan Matthews - While he looks decent, I don't really see what the hype, like "baby T.O.," is about. I don't see any blazing speed, tremendous strength, explosiveness or razzle dazzle. And when he awkwardly "shake-n-bakes" he doesn't fool anyone. To me, he looks like a college player. He was used effectively in bubble screens and short passes, but didn't seem to be able to get open downfield. He is a big improvement over Avant though since he does catch it and turn upfield for good yards instead of falling down. He also doesn't point to the sky after 4 yard gains.
Josh Huff - didn't do all that much as a receiver, but had a kickoff return for a TD. And then another return where he got rocked and wrecked his shoulder.
Jaylen Watkins - got burned badly vs. the Bears but also made some decent plays and had a pick. He'll get better as he figures things out. We hope.
Taylor Hart - probably destined for the practice squad.
Ed Reynolds - probably destined to be cut.
Beau Allen - stood out because he has long hair and is fat, but also because his play and effort was excellent. He most likely will rotate in at nose tackle.
Henry Josey - I liked this guys quickness and moves and hope he makes the team, but I think he will be cut. I prefer him over second year RB, Matthew Tucker. But he may lose out because apparently Tucker is better at pass protection. Tucker also has more size.
Cody Parkey - brought in via a trade to challenge Henery for the kicking job and hit on his only 2 chances, both which were over 50 yards. Sample size is extremely small.
Saturday the roster will be semi-finalized - here's a
cut tracker via Birds 24/7. Sunday I will publish the super important "season prediction post."